Files
MikrotikManager/docs/mcp-users-native-targets-acceptance-20261106.json
T

128 lines
5.8 KiB
JSON

{
"kind": "users-native-binding-local-review-draft",
"draft": false,
"scope": "Fresh native existence/type/peer validation and canonical persisted binding verification",
"sourcePins": {
"backend/src/modules/users/binding-target.ts": "c67fdadd908743b10cf51dd08b98c1aed3554ef82f2c549f8a532b17ce4c6335",
"backend/src/modules/users/binding-native-read.ts": "bffd3633a6d814359ffd95cc9f5483fbd6fa5219c08dd0f356d77f282fe3578e",
"backend/src/modules/users/service/users-service.ts": "5f80908864320ea39209c453e03280e35c3422440e065aedb5472ce639b0994a",
"backend/src/modules/mcp/actions.ts": "a0d0cecde6ed03a8469f98f8476602755b3b7fbfa5d6940fcfb92536c87e4f78",
"backend/src/modules/mcp/runtime.ts": "a610329be977bf36946d0ffe4fae0c8a03683b134cac9617e0e6b1def732a629",
"backend/src/services/ipsec-live.ts": "3bc952c50d4286a22cc7f79ee08d6e11fc9ab04a5ebc388b85af27e1d55ed397",
"backend/src/modules/users/binding-target.test.ts": "2dd14b236b61d4cf0bc4c09e19e7f72b02d0d69a436ce4486220528e5536cfc8",
"backend/src/test/mcp-users-bindings.ts": "c05b3d5dad261b2508b666a78dfd6a825edbcc84bf2836abd4c3872d8e450f5d"
},
"evidencePins": {
"tmp/mcp-users-native-targets-pure-20261106.log": "076a6c6607ee7d08d8c6cd35758fb5cc3b3c4789fcd765867b34e3bbb2398a83",
"tmp/mcp-users-native-targets-canonical-pg-20261106.log": "6db3c3431f6a269b52f86ebab4a71e6a7d24ddb59a3f25d2ded9672aba048d19",
"tmp/mcp-users-native-targets-build-20261106.log": "2a6faba091965b7708b2bb3d1673a822ff17f7c891074b60aff1c9d4a50e320a",
"tmp/mcp-users-native-targets-standard-reviewed-20261106.log": "b1c44452fbbee79fa0b5c8a500201901d8feb349a05176653b2d48d7529ed9a5",
"tmp/mcp-users-native-targets-users-20261106.log": "17f5cd57eef8ead5a264f68bbd54628003c4b8eea30cf489ba8e706589e95fee"
},
"review": {
"blockingFindings": [],
"canonicalVerification": "Returned created binding id + server + trimmed interface + explicit requested type + normalizeBindingPeer by persisted type",
"pureCasesObserved": 37,
"ownedPostgresRouterOsStubPassLogObserved": true,
"paddedNamePeerAndIgnoredOrdinaryKeyInOwnedFixture": true,
"rootReportsOwnedSession50198Pass": true,
"newTestsExecutedByReviewer": 0
},
"limitations": {
"nativeRouterAcceptance": false,
"portalAcceptance": false,
"atomicNativeToDatabaseTransaction": false,
"vpnOnlineOrForwardingVerified": false,
"postgresDumpRestoreRun": false,
"standardRegistrationPendingTerminal": false,
"standardUsersDbCasesSkippedInObservedLog": true,
"wholeInstallation2GbAccepted": false,
"externalAdminNativeObjectMutationBetweenReadAndSqlRemainsPossible": true,
"standardUsersDbCasesLaterPassedOnOwnPostgres": true
},
"writes": {
"productionEditsByReviewer": 0,
"remoteRequests": 0,
"packetEdits": 0
},
"date": "2026-11-06",
"fullPlanComplete": false,
"problem": "Missing native interfaces and nonexistent WG/IPsec peers could be bound; caller type could override actual native type. Canonicalized valid input could persist then falsely fail verification.",
"implementation": {
"freshFixedNativeCatalogues": true,
"snapshotHistoryNotUsedForCreateValidation": true,
"sourceEndpointIncarnationAndCurrentMcpAuthorityFenced": true,
"sqlUniqueConstraintRetained": true,
"createdBindingIdAndCanonicalNamePeerVerified": true,
"nativeConfigurationWrites": 0,
"nativeGetByteLimit": 1048576,
"catalogueRowLimit": 10000,
"nativeReadPhaseBudgetMs": 10000,
"blockedDatabaseWaitStrictElapsedBoundClaimed": false,
"privateNativePayloadReturned": false,
"managedPskClientEligibilityPreserved": true
},
"validation": {
"pure": {
"path": "tmp/mcp-users-native-targets-pure-20261106.log",
"sha256": "076a6c6607ee7d08d8c6cd35758fb5cc3b3c4789fcd765867b34e3bbb2398a83",
"exitCode": 0
},
"canonicalOwnedSqlHttp": {
"path": "tmp/mcp-users-native-targets-canonical-pg-20261106.log",
"sha256": "6db3c3431f6a269b52f86ebab4a71e6a7d24ddb59a3f25d2ded9672aba048d19",
"exitCode": 0
},
"finalBackendBuild": {
"path": "tmp/mcp-users-native-targets-canonical-build-20261106.log",
"sha256": "2a6faba091965b7708b2bb3d1673a822ff17f7c891074b60aff1c9d4a50e320a",
"exitCode": 0
},
"standardMcpBeforeCanonicalVerifierFix": {
"path": "tmp/mcp-users-native-targets-standard-reviewed-20261106.log",
"sha256": "b1c44452fbbee79fa0b5c8a500201901d8feb349a05176653b2d48d7529ed9a5",
"exitCode": 0
},
"registeredStandardUsers": {
"path": "tmp/mcp-users-native-targets-registered-users-20261106.log",
"sha256": "446b9cdc5ad90cb5ae38c3818674b5fbcf7c309d0e60eca4d663e58216ce1534",
"exitCode": 0
},
"canonicalVerifierCoveredByOwnedSqlAfterFix": true,
"standardUsersDbCaseSkippedWithoutAmbientPostgres": true,
"dedicatedOwnedPostgresPassedSeparately": true,
"types": [
"ether",
"bridge",
"vlan",
"vxlan",
"gre",
"other",
"wg",
"ipsec"
],
"managedPskAdditionalCase": true,
"allNineCasesUsePaddedCanonicalInputs": true,
"standardUsersWithOwnPostgres": {
"exitCode": 0,
"path": "tmp/mcp-users-standard-owned-pg-20261106.log",
"sha256": "04a2d525d762a3be09f508424be829270aed293ed24da1f601fb40a49fbd6f58",
"uniqueAndCascadeActuallyExecuted": true,
"selector37Included": true,
"logsSqlAlsoPassed": true,
"ambientSkipFromEarlierRunRetainedAsHistoryOnly": true
}
},
"testRegistration": {
"pure37IncludedInTestUsers": true,
"package": {
"path": "backend/package.json",
"sha256": "31607cbfc5cb7948256a56a936e9a6633484e6a906609b1362cb94b1c5e538c5",
"exitCode": 0
},
"changedOnlyAfterV33Terminal": true,
"frozenNativeV33ArchiveOrOperatorChanged": false
},
"deployed": false
}