Files
MikrotikManager/docs/mcp-vrf-all68-component-acceptance-20261102.json
T

608 lines
22 KiB
JSON

{
"format": "mcp-vrf-all68-component-acceptance-v1",
"date": "2026-11-02",
"recordedAt": "2026-11-01T17:47:09.446633+00:00",
"acceptedScoped": true,
"scope": "All ten current VRF production fixture slices,68 cases on one fresh retained owned PostgreSQL; genuine SQL/MCP authentication-policy-approval/crypto and native HTTP loopback, not actual RouterOS forwarding",
"rootSession": 68349,
"rootExitCode": 0,
"attempt": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt",
"sameOwnedPg": true,
"sliceCount": 10,
"caseCount": 68,
"budgets": {
"baselineMs": 240000,
"otherNineSlicesMs": 120000,
"exitConfirmationGuard": "slice budget +15000ms",
"operationWaitMs": 60000,
"nativeReadMs": 10000,
"streamPerChildBytes": 1048576,
"additionalCapsRaised": false,
"allElevenBaselineCasesRequired": true
},
"slices": [
{
"slice": "baseline",
"cases": 11,
"capMs": 240000,
"exitCode": 0,
"childPid": 73924,
"childExitConfirmed": true,
"actualSql": true,
"actualCrypto": true,
"actualMcpAuthPolicyApprovalRuntime": true,
"fakeVerifier": false,
"loopbackNativeWrites": 10,
"loopbackRawReads": 1661,
"rawShape": "authoritative recorded v5 bridge vectors",
"acceptedCases": [
"vrf-create",
"vrf-rename",
"vrf-disable",
"vrf-reenable",
"vrf-membership-transfer-a-to-b",
"vrf-delete-addresses-remain",
"ignored",
"collateral",
"wrong-ack",
"lost-ack",
"post-intent-revoke"
],
"actualRouter": false,
"forwardingVerified": false
},
{
"slice": "physical",
"cases": 7,
"capMs": 120000,
"exitCode": 0,
"childPid": 68708,
"childExitConfirmed": true,
"actualSql": true,
"actualCrypto": true,
"actualMcpAuthPolicyApprovalRuntime": true,
"fakeVerifier": false,
"loopbackNativeWrites": 6,
"loopbackRawReads": 1076,
"rawShape": "synthetic physical/VLAN concrete-parent projection derived from v5 context vectors",
"acceptedCases": [
"vrf-create",
"vrf-rename",
"vrf-disable",
"vrf-reenable",
"vrf-membership-transfer-a-to-b",
"vrf-delete-addresses-remain",
"original-parent-drift-before-dispatch"
],
"actualRouter": false,
"forwardingVerified": false
},
{
"slice": "vlan",
"cases": 9,
"capMs": 120000,
"exitCode": 0,
"childPid": 32624,
"childExitConfirmed": true,
"actualSql": true,
"actualCrypto": true,
"actualMcpAuthPolicyApprovalRuntime": true,
"fakeVerifier": false,
"loopbackNativeWrites": 6,
"loopbackRawReads": 1165,
"rawShape": "synthetic physical/VLAN concrete-parent projection derived from v5 context vectors",
"acceptedCases": [
"vrf-create",
"vrf-rename",
"vrf-disable",
"vrf-reenable",
"vrf-membership-transfer-a-to-b",
"vrf-delete-addresses-remain",
"original-parent-drift-before-dispatch",
"closed-physical-parent-protection-deny",
"closed-parent-object-budget-atomic-refusal"
],
"actualRouter": false,
"forwardingVerified": false
},
{
"slice": "disabled",
"cases": 9,
"capMs": 120000,
"exitCode": 0,
"childPid": 4488,
"childExitConfirmed": true,
"actualSql": true,
"actualCrypto": true,
"actualMcpAuthPolicyApprovalRuntime": true,
"fakeVerifier": false,
"loopbackNativeWrites": 9,
"loopbackRawReads": 1556,
"rawShape": "synthetic disabled-CREATE derived from v5 inactive vector; never-enabled defaults not actual CHR",
"acceptedCases": [
"disabled-create",
"disabled-enable-first",
"vrf-rename",
"vrf-disable",
"vrf-reenable",
"vrf-membership-transfer-a-to-b",
"vrf-delete-addresses-remain",
"disabled-create-direct-delete",
"disabled-delete"
],
"actualRouter": false,
"forwardingVerified": false
},
{
"slice": "mixed",
"cases": 7,
"capMs": 120000,
"exitCode": 0,
"childPid": 70540,
"childExitConfirmed": true,
"actualSql": true,
"actualCrypto": true,
"actualMcpAuthPolicyApprovalRuntime": true,
"fakeVerifier": false,
"loopbackNativeWrites": 6,
"loopbackRawReads": 1086,
"rawShape": "synthetic physical/VLAN concrete-parent projection derived from v5 context vectors",
"acceptedCases": [
"vrf-create",
"vrf-rename",
"vrf-disable",
"vrf-reenable",
"vrf-membership-transfer-a-to-b",
"vrf-delete-addresses-remain",
"original-parent-drift-before-dispatch"
],
"actualRouter": false,
"forwardingVerified": false
},
{
"slice": "reconcile",
"cases": 6,
"capMs": 120000,
"exitCode": 0,
"childPid": 28940,
"childExitConfirmed": true,
"actualSql": true,
"actualCrypto": true,
"actualMcpAuthPolicyApprovalRuntime": true,
"fakeVerifier": false,
"loopbackNativeWrites": 1,
"loopbackRawReads": 228,
"rawShape": "synthetic physical/VLAN concrete-parent projection derived from v5 context vectors",
"acceptedCases": [
"vrf-create",
"whole-companion-readonly-match",
"whole-companion-readonly-drift",
"readonly-reviewed-telemetry",
"explicit-no-inverse-revision",
"unverified-checkpoint-is-unknown"
],
"actualRouter": false,
"forwardingVerified": false
},
{
"slice": "sql-journal",
"cases": 1,
"capMs": 120000,
"exitCode": 0,
"childPid": 67960,
"childExitConfirmed": true,
"actualSql": true,
"actualCrypto": true,
"actualMcpAuthPolicyApprovalRuntime": true,
"fakeVerifier": false,
"loopbackNativeWrites": 1,
"loopbackRawReads": 119,
"rawShape": "synthetic physical/VLAN concrete-parent projection derived from v5 context vectors",
"acceptedCases": [
"actual-ACK-journal-SQL-failure-known-write-no-replay"
],
"actualRouter": false,
"forwardingVerified": false
},
{
"slice": "guards",
"cases": 11,
"capMs": 120000,
"exitCode": 0,
"childPid": 27420,
"childExitConfirmed": true,
"actualSql": true,
"actualCrypto": true,
"actualMcpAuthPolicyApprovalRuntime": true,
"fakeVerifier": false,
"loopbackNativeWrites": 7,
"loopbackRawReads": 1208,
"rawShape": "synthetic physical/VLAN concrete-parent projection derived from v5 context vectors",
"acceptedCases": [
"explicit-admission-required-create",
"explicit-admission-required-update",
"explicit-admission-required-delete",
"guard-setup-create",
"late-approved-external-gateway-zero-writes",
"contradictory-PATCH-ACK-no-replay",
"vrf-rename",
"vrf-disable",
"vrf-reenable",
"vrf-membership-transfer-a-to-b",
"contradictory-DELETE-ACK-no-replay"
],
"actualRouter": false,
"forwardingVerified": false
},
{
"slice": "coexistence",
"cases": 3,
"capMs": 120000,
"exitCode": 0,
"childPid": 69404,
"childExitConfirmed": true,
"actualSql": true,
"actualCrypto": true,
"actualMcpAuthPolicyApprovalRuntime": true,
"fakeVerifier": false,
"loopbackNativeWrites": 5,
"loopbackRawReads": 952,
"rawShape": "synthetic physical/VLAN concrete-parent projection derived from v5 context vectors",
"acceptedCases": [
"fresh-approved-foreign-route-firewall-primary-metadata-coexist",
"after-approval-unrelated-foreign-drift-zero-writes",
"causal-missing-LL-member-MAC-drift-refused-before-write"
],
"actualRouter": false,
"forwardingVerified": false
},
{
"slice": "alias",
"cases": 4,
"capMs": 120000,
"exitCode": 0,
"childPid": 77992,
"childExitConfirmed": true,
"actualSql": true,
"actualCrypto": true,
"actualMcpAuthPolicyApprovalRuntime": true,
"fakeVerifier": false,
"loopbackNativeWrites": 1,
"loopbackRawReads": 406,
"rawShape": "synthetic physical/VLAN concrete-parent projection derived from v5 context vectors",
"acceptedCases": [
"managed-prefix-and-original-parent-protection-preserved",
"alias-original-extra-dependency-drift-zero-writes",
"public-v2-and-fresh-native-version-fences-no-replay",
"alias-only-grant-actual-apply-canonical-tool-denied"
],
"actualRouter": false,
"forwardingVerified": false
}
],
"loopbackTotals": {
"writes": 52,
"rawReads": 9457,
"actualRouter": false,
"forwardingVerified": false
},
"lifecycle": {
"scope": "owned-current-all-ten-vrf-slices-68-required",
"rootGraphSha256": "9ae9bb2ea175a15d18648a5fa6576b703aa629a41473a3e71ea454b6dbfcf237",
"sourceFileCount": 1912,
"startedAt": "2026-11-01T17:28:17.023Z",
"status": "terminal",
"phase": "done",
"childExitConfirmed": true,
"pgStopConfirmed": true,
"pgExitConfirmed": true,
"pgPid": 76000,
"pgExitCode": 1,
"pgExitSignal": null,
"pgExitEventObserved": true,
"ownDirectoryRemoved": true,
"sourcePinsUnchanged": true,
"accepted": true,
"exitCode": 0,
"completedCases": 68,
"finishedAt": "2026-11-01T17:36:31.809Z"
},
"sourceProof": {
"capturedSourceFiles": 1912,
"historicalRunGraphSha256": "9ae9bb2ea175a15d18648a5fa6576b703aa629a41473a3e71ea454b6dbfcf237",
"savedSourcePinsExactlyMatchCapturedGraph": true,
"sourceUnchangedDuringRun": true,
"currentRootRecomputedOrComparedToOldExpectedHashes": false,
"archivalGraphComparisons": [
{
"archivalGraph": {
"file": "tmp/mcp-current44-components-final-20261101-pins.json",
"bytes": 308296,
"sha256": "dfc3632c26401518cef4810ca98f74616565b4c790f67f6958de7c498c8e5f5d"
},
"archivalSourceFiles": 1912,
"newRunSourceFiles": 1912,
"added": [],
"removed": [],
"changed": [
{
"path": "backend/src/test/mcp-host-files.ts",
"beforeSha256": "6735f1d9e51ca57c944db51a4ff9f176cac31f0a15c1c2b0c28b2886757e7fbd",
"runSha256": "6231cfdf6bb2090dce3a12fa1d07c9e27389a8b5162535ad9b449fb51a469a81"
}
],
"comparisonKind": "captured graph versus captured graph, no current-root expected-hash comparison"
},
{
"archivalGraph": {
"file": "tmp/mcp-current44-components-primary-20261101-pins.json",
"bytes": 308296,
"sha256": "741d2bc01ca79a09763f6d44bc95a4c38ca6916804de99ca1f90be7c3a98d4aa"
},
"archivalSourceFiles": 1912,
"newRunSourceFiles": 1912,
"added": [],
"removed": [],
"changed": [
{
"path": "backend/src/test/mcp-host-files.ts",
"beforeSha256": "6735f1d9e51ca57c944db51a4ff9f176cac31f0a15c1c2b0c28b2886757e7fbd",
"runSha256": "6231cfdf6bb2090dce3a12fa1d07c9e27389a8b5162535ad9b449fb51a469a81"
}
],
"comparisonKind": "captured graph versus captured graph, no current-root expected-hash comparison"
}
]
},
"rawEvidence": [
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/baseline-fixture.log",
"bytes": 20631,
"sha256": "f50983be91f0d9067cbec164c13f01e30c18c0a489ca0c7ff9c0f2d2b94e2592"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/baseline-result.json",
"bytes": 368,
"sha256": "684abd9b774d4283b3fccfe6d6ecbd0817309a84818ec07e85a16b9ec66e4cc4"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/physical-fixture.log",
"bytes": 14219,
"sha256": "8a7a13ef2506b9c8b2226a33423f9944541217780b51c6ae9e664a32e7156b6e"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/physical-result.json",
"bytes": 366,
"sha256": "ac943bac28746cbc01c506c44ba49c464e21a2fb93dcd103a25e81cdfc5b58d8"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/vlan-fixture.log",
"bytes": 14306,
"sha256": "de0e900e045ab6f5798383d6584ea74ab2e468794f7c6280bf02ae86afbe20d3"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/vlan-result.json",
"bytes": 362,
"sha256": "7a11a056dc3798fc4be1b3126eba366f6862dd8c9c293275c25e12c1080c629f"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/disabled-fixture.log",
"bytes": 19188,
"sha256": "9ad1ece4d6c075b21ee1693c4ae79c9cb880fb0a44fd5203055f81d80c40c797"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/disabled-result.json",
"bytes": 365,
"sha256": "3b7dcf03340644d7fb13812ac2ee4206e7e0912b333cc0c3076cd501cf42df58"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/mixed-fixture.log",
"bytes": 14182,
"sha256": "e3268936b504e9cec352d1d69eada328f0bde8da96d6c04e26ce4af61f82e457"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/mixed-result.json",
"bytes": 363,
"sha256": "b6b910e0258e04a1dd1033d25a6aa48c531c5b2e0dcdcc9d6fdb077028700ed6"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/reconcile-fixture.log",
"bytes": 3595,
"sha256": "e66b3261c094f0125e4c9c6e98eee529d78746c9c426f38730dcd05304e6622f"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/reconcile-result.json",
"bytes": 365,
"sha256": "8720c02e128f6300b3ddb10dfbbe2b4f55ed8e32e42d826fb9ce22d7b8a4a4b9"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/sql-journal-fixture.log",
"bytes": 2328,
"sha256": "7d017de1556139032387f026bee6ae1bc96465f9409f042c2a86c767b5611294"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/sql-journal-result.json",
"bytes": 367,
"sha256": "2bb0f4d78eeaa577e3ca5d7d1f34b6575bfcc855291ecff7286afa7631a65c6d"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/guards-fixture.log",
"bytes": 14309,
"sha256": "91b9a8d7999165562c3abd116ed1d3cef4f2e4ea1b4100454f3701e81f5a4daf"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/guards-result.json",
"bytes": 365,
"sha256": "30ba96aaa98116df3150fcaa0b7611643aecd1bf090c5648ce2d3001563a752c"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/coexistence-fixture.log",
"bytes": 12305,
"sha256": "67445219c3ffd08eb7798f70ad387b3b548a8c2df1888b3b8c9a86e4570006af"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/coexistence-result.json",
"bytes": 369,
"sha256": "b41b86b10aafc27c9b83bc33d2344a2a2ff303d6c2a4aace5eb7ba87059eb0f5"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/alias-fixture.log",
"bytes": 4481,
"sha256": "d8bab3f5b7d79f86a02e6b39105c2bb50bb443e76dc0d33833f9dcc19cb32fee"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/alias-result.json",
"bytes": 361,
"sha256": "dfa08a3f2a1b13baae2da8809aa0c265ab9a4a28b11a03c829b149c95404d449"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/diagnostic.json",
"bytes": 606,
"sha256": "e334e7d3968b18cf279d9bad4d174c1efe83dff72dd2ff4a664bc226fbf67c83"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/all-slices-acceptance.json",
"bytes": 2033,
"sha256": "a7c0d6227e1b87f0b8b439fc649e349998f64d112987c8621c263043d557d933"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/attempt-myB6Mt/source-pins.json",
"bytes": 292939,
"sha256": "5d61138489bf6c069a1deb6a0e7bbaeb53216a591626feb82328ccfb3f27ab9f"
}
],
"stageVerification": {
"stageCriticalInputsChecked": 7,
"mismatches": [],
"criticalInputs": [
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/run-all-slices.mjs",
"bytes": 7271,
"sha256": "26b3ac900145f02a4522114a668f22d0a2474c968fab1edb259cd01099d57600",
"expectedSha256": "26b3ac900145f02a4522114a668f22d0a2474c968fab1edb259cd01099d57600",
"matches": true
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/all-slices-profile.mjs",
"bytes": 6862,
"sha256": "92b766b37c2710084814993fdccea70946a882381a1e7ccefa1584a78c4523bc",
"expectedSha256": "92b766b37c2710084814993fdccea70946a882381a1e7ccefa1584a78c4523bc",
"matches": true
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/vrf-production-execution-owned.mts",
"bytes": 36037,
"sha256": "23a7d65861490503be044914323c63455778d71c976b3201a0ef59a22498a390",
"expectedSha256": "23a7d65861490503be044914323c63455778d71c976b3201a0ef59a22498a390",
"matches": true
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/startup-preflight.mjs",
"bytes": 2629,
"sha256": "406a23e66ec761a8ca24f271dee29099355e33c6b7561f9e66408799b14f7925",
"expectedSha256": "406a23e66ec761a8ca24f271dee29099355e33c6b7561f9e66408799b14f7925",
"matches": true
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/literal-import-map.json",
"bytes": 1145,
"sha256": "5dd43faa0bf6dea271dec50a0c11cc09d00d486efad11604403967e6bb4e687c",
"expectedSha256": "5dd43faa0bf6dea271dec50a0c11cc09d00d486efad11604403967e6bb4e687c",
"matches": true
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/all-slices-review.patch",
"bytes": 11875,
"sha256": "c1eed5d73d47f72b84a3573bef19cb5a3fbb1436bb9b883dc3966863f76bf932",
"expectedSha256": "c1eed5d73d47f72b84a3573bef19cb5a3fbb1436bb9b883dc3966863f76bf932",
"matches": true
},
{
"file": "docs/mcp-chr-vrf-companion-native-v5.json",
"bytes": 669183,
"sha256": "8d187a2e3615f6e108fdcaefb89f2eae5c76eca924fada1033ba1bcbb8fde55d",
"expectedSha256": "8d187a2e3615f6e108fdcaefb89f2eae5c76eca924fada1033ba1bcbb8fde55d",
"matches": true
}
],
"additionalCriticalArtifacts": [
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/review-pins.json",
"bytes": 1474,
"sha256": "32dce9ac9feb40388badad81bd596c7b50b0b1bd993e4a8f5a0de80d7a41e063"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/final-root-source-pins.json",
"bytes": 308371,
"sha256": "9ae9bb2ea175a15d18648a5fa6576b703aa629a41473a3e71ea454b6dbfcf237"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/startup-preflight-final.json",
"bytes": 443,
"sha256": "0655aff5c9baac3daa37ee27c9ea0346e9123dd167b5b5f32535bbc4240b46a0"
},
{
"file": "tmp/mcp-vrf-all68-staged-20261101/startup-negative-final.log",
"bytes": 734,
"sha256": "bf0db3d9a2be4f78caf3f7742c6315f333b4bd22491dc3d45a396e2f1cbb7a2c"
}
],
"actualLoaderMissingOwnGuardAccepted": true,
"historicalStagingMetadataPendingFlagsNotCurrentRunStatus": true
},
"scopeLimits": {
"actualSql": true,
"actualCrypto": true,
"actualMcpAuthPolicyApprovalRuntime": true,
"fakeVerifier": false,
"nativeLoopbackOnly": true,
"actualRouter": false,
"forwardingVerified": false,
"disabledNeverEnabledDefaults": "synthetic disabled-CREATE derived from recorded v5 inactive vector; not actual CHR never-enabled raw capture",
"physicalVlanAndOtherDerivedContexts": "synthetic projections from v5 recorded context; see each rawShape",
"wholeNativeAccepted": false,
"wholeProjectAccepted": false,
"wholeInstallation2GbAccepted": false,
"singleCommandProfiles38Accepted": false,
"livePortalAccepted": false,
"READY": false
},
"adjacentEvidence": {
"previousProfilesReport": {
"file": "docs/mcp-current44-components-profiles-partial-20261101.json",
"bytes": 2247,
"sha256": "3c747b90911ffd24349c5cfcd47d628a8a7593b6b2d43092c69a6ac61846db4b"
},
"previousRunSession": 85600,
"previous37ProfilesPassed": true,
"previousFullMatrixAccepted": false,
"previousOnlyFailedProfile": "test:vrf:production",
"newRunIsComponentOnlyNotCombined38Command": true,
"primary10566": {
"status": "REFUSED",
"reason": "host-files stale assertion expected401 after pause; actual403 with valid owner JWT",
"statusEvidence": {
"file": "tmp/mcp-current44-components-primary-20261101-status.json",
"bytes": 727,
"sha256": "6be1a3478cfa0464418fba66071e0d5c66fecfba8aac56eaf3081bde76254cba"
},
"resolvedByThisVrfRun": false
},
"hostFocus62651": {
"status": "loader refusal before case",
"sourceUnchangedAndCleanup": "root-reported true",
"functionalAcceptance": false,
"nextHarnessFix": "routing agent owns CLI TSX fileURLv3 correction"
},
"sourceDeltaSincePreviousGraphs": "only backend/src/test/mcp-host-files.ts expected401→403/PERMISSION_DENIED/no-secret/sameJWT-management200; test is imported by integration.test.ts, not VRF fixture",
"actualSourceBehaviorChangeForVrf": false
},
"notes": [
"Actual PG native shutdown exit1 is observed, not claimed as exit0.",
"Raw logs/results are retained outside the removed owned PG directory. All ten child exits and exact retained PG exit event are confirmed.",
"Historical staged review-pins pending-capture labels predate root capture/run and are not interpreted as current status.",
"Old partial/full-matrix/primary and failed loader receipts remain unchanged; component68 completion does not turn those refused commands into passes.",
"Only these two permanent documentation files were written; no source/build/PG/capture/current tracker edits or DATA cost stage mutations."
]
}