Files
MikrotikManager/docs/mcp-bandwidth-sql-journal-acceptance-20261026.json
T

115 lines
7.3 KiB
JSON

{
"stage": "Opt-in common bandwidth SQL journal accepted on disposable PostgreSQL",
"date": "2026-10-26",
"fullPlanComplete": false,
"sqlProposalAccepted": true,
"publicSpeedAdapterAccepted": false,
"normalMigrationCount": 39,
"normalEnrollmentChanged": false,
"newNormalMigrationMarkerCreated": false,
"inventory": {
"tools": 358,
"pending": 5,
"mediated": 195,
"routes": 262,
"excluded": 62
},
"sql": {
"transactionBudgetMs": 10000,
"alwaysGuards": 9,
"tables": [
"bandwidth_attempts",
"bandwidth_node_occupancy",
"bandwidth_attempt_events"
],
"statementBudgetMs": 5000,
"immutableBindingAndOwnership": true,
"defaultPoolOrIo": false,
"occupancyKeyExcludesGeneration": true,
"fixedSearchPathFunctions": 6,
"allPriorEventsHmacChecked": true,
"singleUseLocalNewAcknowledgement": true,
"unknownBusyNoAutomaticRelease": true,
"atomicPairReservation": true
},
"actualAcceptance": {
"proposalOnly": true,
"normalMigrationCount": 39,
"normalEnrollmentChanged": false,
"productionRestoreAccepted": false,
"runtimeDispatchIntegrated": false,
"nativeChrCalls": 0,
"actualCommitAckLosses": 4,
"eventCount": 37,
"cases": [
"reserve rollback before real COMMIT leaves neither half-pair nor attempt",
"two independent processes/backend PIDs: A-B blocks B-C/reversed B-A; disjoint C-D succeeds; repeat has no new ACK",
"concurrent independent connections reserve intersecting pairs atomically: exactly one winner",
"actual reserve COMMIT then lost ACK retains pair; independent process cannot reclaim",
"actual arm COMMIT then lost ACK: persisted armed pair survives fresh store and has no repeat reserve ACK",
"real pg_terminate_backend of committed arm backend AFTER loopback dispatch, while remote held running: new process remains blocked; socket close/quarantine retains pair",
"quarantine lost-commit never clears armed occupancy",
"quarantine rollback-before-commit never clears armed occupancy",
"real completion COMMIT ACK loss releases both only with terminal proof; stale complete/quarantine/no-send never clears newer owner",
"forged terminal/no-send evidence refused; changed endpoint epoch does not free canonical node",
"server DELETE does not cascade into canonical occupancy; active attempt DELETE rejected and pair preserved",
"quarantined canonical nodes cannot be reclaimed by new control/credential generation; expired altered binding cannot rearm",
"same-instance local admission arm versus reserved cancel race: one local winner; not evidence of a database CAS race",
"actual two-client distinct-backend reserved UPDATE CAS race after shared BEGIN barrier: arm versus release, one committed winner, loser rows=0/ROLLBACK, complete event HMAC and 0-or-2 occupancy",
"actual DML guards refuse immutable binding, node identity/owner replacement, active occupancy DELETE, event UPDATE/DELETE, attempt DELETE and full journal TRUNCATE; exact rows unchanged",
"owned replica mode in three separate rolled-back transactions cannot DELETE active attempt/occupancy or TRUNCATE journal; nine ALWAYS triggers and six fixed search_path functions verified in pg_catalog",
"real wall-clock original execute expiry refuses arm; bounded original cleanup can quarantine without freeing pair",
"real relation lock and 200ms owned deadline destroy blocked adapter backend; after unlock no late COMMIT/occupancy",
"uppercase original UUID spelling is preserved in new ACKs while PostgreSQL identity and event HMACs use canonical UUID",
"every persisted transition event verified with keyed fixture HMAC including terminal completion proof",
"real pg_dump/pg_restore into separate owned DB preserves exact proposal table hashes/unknown occupancy, nine ALWAYS triggers, six fixed search_path functions and 39 markers; corrupted archive header rejected"
],
"limitations": [
"No production native transport/broker integration or schema/control enrollment: SQL proposal only",
"No real remote-completion/physical identity enrollment; terminal evidence is explicitly synthetic keyed fixture proof",
"No aged retention/automatic GC integration; no automatic unknown release policy is supplied",
"Deleting synthetic servers tests canonical-key independence; there is no implemented server-to-physical-node mapping"
]
},
"validation": {
"backendBuild": "passed",
"eslint": "passed",
"strictSourceAndTests": "passed",
"ownedSql": "passed",
"coverage": "358 tools/195 mediated/62 excluded/5 pending",
"diffCheck": "passed"
},
"limits": [
"No production database role isolation claim; owner/superuser DDL control is outside these structural guards",
"Private terminal/no-send authenticity is supplied by trusted callbacks; the owned test uses synthetic keyed evidence",
"Dump/restore checks proposal data and guard metadata plus corrupted archive header; production archive authenticity and restored dispatch readiness remain unproven",
"No canonical physical-node issuer, trusted control-generation bootstrap, normal schema enrollment, capacity/retention integration, mandatory transport wiring or full public speed workflow"
],
"next": [
"complete trusted generation/canonical-node enrollment and capacity/restore boundary",
"wire mandatory bandwidth capability into all fixed native dispatch callers",
"integrate complete speed-test/history/failure/no-replay service and public MCP adapter",
"repeat actual public runtime and multi-process acceptance on the final enrolled source"
],
"productionRestoreAccepted": false,
"runtimeDispatchIntegrated": false,
"realChrTouched": false,
"productionDatabaseTouched": false,
"deployed": false,
"sha256": {
"backend/src/services/bandwidth-admission-storage.ts": "ac2d4f345b5eb27a7b83c999619e4d7247eba137d495e7d31fc5969300b31687",
"backend/src/services/bandwidth-admission-schema.ts": "1853e2de43797454ca335d7d4069421e6737afaac2c0bd7e087408529e68e172",
"backend/src/services/bandwidth-admission.sql.test.ts": "e1eab6197fcf74a6fc00a3169e562d6342f4f934b53c88cefc2bcc0b6f4e1b9f",
"backend/src/services/bandwidth-admission-process.sql-helper.ts": "8898c09aff079e8a205aa316a4bef9ef98b74b0010e2ac7715df1cc6d56b1f14",
"backend/src/services/bandwidth-admission.ts": "4754026971d1c420f370b1632b003cc5c923a00cea233cff5ec78ecb212423ad",
"backend/scripts/test-mcp-postgres.mjs": "89a4ef86eca4d33079ef927d3b65daf3df589cc7fa5e4738c40c3915fb4a6f08",
"backend/package.json": "21bc48dbacb256c710fd2f6463ba750a5add828fbb233ec5d3e0a7d61d04ef62",
"tmp/bandwidth-admission-sql-final.log": "caf0bc0d44543fb3b0e6ffe4dd40d61407f5be2e04dad769ceb504c4c4666bbf",
"tmp/bandwidth-sql-types-final.log": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"tmp/bandwidth-sql-lint-final.log": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855",
"tmp/bandwidth-sql-build-final.log": "4f26b355b57fa516cf22f7286ea65b24c6b8d066f666278b5e704f5aa528e2d3",
"tmp/bandwidth-sql-coverage-final.log": "f12c8403e4ad08e750e71565ce15df5eb44154076e5acd8991b22b6eb2a50214",
"tmp/bandwidth-sql-diff-final.log": "21d72af86c39e228166bc1e02a6fbe5ffad8740746e46adb13ff42c84a85ae67"
}
}