This way we avoid parsing messages with unexpected message IDs, which
might not even be possible if we don't have the keys anymore. However,
the next commit should avoid the latter and this way we avoid deriving
keys for retransmits or unexpected messages.
This also changes how retransmits for fragmented messages are triggered.
Previously, we waited for all fragments and reconstructed the message
before retransmitting the response. Now we only track the first
fragment and if we receive a retransmit of it respond immediately
without waiting for other fragments (which are now ignored). This is in
compliance with RFC 7383, section 2.6.1, and can avoid issues if there
are lots of fragments.
This way we can use the IKE_REKEYED state for both redundant and old SAs
to suppress ike_updown().
In the ike-delete task we don't suppress events in state IKE_REKEYING as
that's the case when we delete an SA the peer is currently rekeying with
multiple key exchanges.
This gives us more flexibility with tasks that return NEED_MORE (currently
none of the colliding tasks do, but that will change with multi-KE
rekeyings). The active task has to check itself if the passive task is
done and should be removed from the task manager.
Since f67199378d ("ike-rekey: Handle undetected collisions also if
delete is delayed") we only ever track tasks of type TASK_IKE_REKEY, so
there is no need to check the type or use the generic task_t interface.
Also changed some of the comments to clarify collision handling.
If the peer successfully rekeyed the SA it gets marked as IKE_REKEYED
and it remains until the peer deletes it (or a timeout). There is no
point in rekeying such SAs again.
IKE_REKEYING will be relevant if we have multi-KE rekeyings and are
waiting for followup key exchanges for a passive rekeying.
Remove outbound SA and policy of rekeyed CHILD_SA since only one is valid.
Otherwise, during update-SA job (when NAT mapping changed), CHILD_SA are
updated and installed one by one, leaving a window where old SAs are being
used. There are also circumstances where the new SA is not processed last.
Closesstrongswan/strongswan#1041
This allows managing trap policies outside of the trap manager.
We'll use this to create trap policies with generic labels if trap policies
can't (or won't) be used (e.g. as responder for roadwarriors).
If update_sa() is called and dynamic traffic selectors are changed using
new addresses, this might cause issues if we continue to use a reqid that
doesn't match the updated traffic selectors. For instance, if the initiator
then uses make-before-break reauth from the new IP. It's also a particular
problem in the SELinux case where multiple CHILD_SAs with specific labels
all share the same (trap) policy with generic label. However, SAs created
after the update would not match due to the new reqid.
With SELinux and without a specific label from an acquire, we abort
establishing the CHILD_SA (for the first one we prefer a childless IKE_SA,
but since that's a separate extension, we fall back to letting the initial
CHILD_SA fail as we won't propose a label).
If trap policies are not installed already (e.g. because it's impossible to
do so like as responder for roadwarriors), this will require installing
them dynamically once the IKE_SA is established.
In SELinux mode we install the configured label on the policies and the
negotiated one on the SAs. This is how it usually is configured where the
policy/configuration has a generic context and the SAs will get the actual
context of the flows assigned (the latter matches the former, so flows
match the policies but will trigger an acquire if no matching SA exists).
In the simple mode we don't pass the label to the kernel and to avoid
duplicate policy errors we also don't use it to acquire unique reqids.
The security labels can be retrieved in a separate list from the
regular traffic selectors. We currently only plan to support a single
security label ourselves, so when generating we don't expect a list.
While combining the actions could cause duplicates (while the SA is
initiated, traffic might trigger the trap and the initiation of another
CHILD_SA), the previous commit should avoid most duplicates. If reuse_ikesa
is disabled, duplicates can't be prevented, though.
This could happen if an acquire is triggered while we respond to a
CREATE_CHILD_SA request from the peer, or if an acquire is triggered
while an IKE_SA (with its existing CHILD_SAs) is reestablished (also
with break-before-make reauthentication). Also catches multiple
manual initiations.
Note that this ignores the traffic selectors from acquires (narrowing to
them seems rare in practice anyway).
Duplicates can still get created if e.g. both peers initiate them
concurrently.